About Us – Rutter Insurance Services is a locally family owned and operated independent insurance agency. Jimmy began in the insurance industry in 1998 after many successful years selling automobiles in the Athens area. Marla soon followed him into the business, leaving behind a career in accounting and income tax preparation. As soon as Brittany finished high school, she too completed her insurance training and licensing and joined the agency. Rutter Insurance Services has two locations; one in Logan, Ohio and the other in McArthur, Ohio, allowing us to serve a large portion of southeast Ohio.

